SEO Blog | Page One Power

Clicks Are Down. Here's How to Win Anyway.

Written by Jon Ball | Nov 18, 2026, 4:48:58 PM

Takeaways from Rand Fishkin's talk at Ahrefs Evolve

Rand Fishkin's message to a room full of SEOs at Ahrefs Evolve was blunt: the era of earning traffic is over, and the brands that win now are the ones that get mentioned, cited and remembered where their audience already spends time.

Impressions are climbing while clicks fall, and it's not just you

I've been in link building for 16 years, and I've watched clients panic as their Search Console charts turn into what Rand calls the "alligator graph": impressions climbing while clicks fall. His talk is the clearest explanation I've heard of why that's happening and what to do about it. I've skipped the jokes (there were plenty) and pulled out the parts that matter if you're trying to show up in AI answers and prove that your marketing works.

Every platform, AI included, is designed to keep people from clicking away

Rand's core point is that AI isn't the only thing eating your traffic. Google, Facebook, Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn and TikTok all want answers to live on their own pages, and AI tools are simply the newest version of the same design.

Open-web traffic is shrinking, but AI is still a small slice of visits

The numbers he shared make the case:

  • Traffic to the open web has fallen about 10% in two years, according to Ahrefs data he showed.
  • AI is still small. In clickstream data from Datos, AI tools accounted for roughly 1.4% of desktop visits, versus about 10% for classic Google search. Search isn't dying; it's just sending fewer clicks.
  • Nearly half of Google searches are for brands people already know. Ranking for unbranded terms reaches a shrinking slice of searchers.
  • About 80% of branded searches now show an AI Overview, so even your own brand name isn't guaranteed to send you the click.
  • Social posts with links get roughly one ninth to one twelfth the reach of posts without them, based on SparkToro's testing.

In AI search, the win is being the brand the answer names

The takeaway for anyone chasing AI visibility: AI tools answer inside the chat and send very little traffic out. Showing up there means being the brand the answer names, not the page it links to.

Attribution is broken, and AI traffic hides inside "direct"

For 25 years, digital marketing won budget because we could show exactly where every visitor came from. Rand argues that's no longer true, and it's not coming back.

  • Tracking is broken by design. Third-party cookies are gone, and roughly 30% of US devices run an ad blocker that also blocks tracking. You can reliably see individuals only after they log in.
  • AI and social referrals show up as "direct." SparkToro's own analytics report 76% of its traffic as direct. Their experiments, and similar work by Will Critchlow at SearchPilot, found that clicks from social platforms and AI tools are routinely stripped of their source and filed as direct.
  • For every visitor, about 1,000 people learn about you somewhere you can't see. Rand and Amanda Natividad's estimate: a podcast mention, a Reddit thread, a ChatGPT answer and a LinkedIn post may all influence a buyer, and none of them get credit.
  • "How did you hear about us?" won't save you. Buyers name the last touch, the one that sounds best, or whatever gets them through the form.

Ads and branded search often take credit for demand other work created

The danger is crediting whoever is closest to the sale. Rand's example is Airbnb: when it cut performance ad spend, about 95% of the traffic those ads had claimed still arrived. Paid search and branded search often collect credit for demand that other work created.

Rand's playbook: show up where your audience already pays attention

Rand closed with a set of rules for marketing in a zero-click world. These are the ones I think matter most for anyone investing in SEO and AI visibility.

Build on rented land and go where your buyers actually are

  1. Build on rented land, on purpose. Google, LinkedIn, YouTube and Reddit can all change the rules on you, and Rand lost 80% of SparkToro's biggest channel when Twitter changed hands. But that's where buyers form opinions, so that's where your brand needs to appear. His advice is to think like a creator, not just a content marketer.
  2. Go where your audience actually is. Borrowing an idea from Dana DiTomaso at Kick Point, map how many of your buyers rely on each channel (search, social, podcasts, communities), then compare that against where your budget goes. Most teams find a mismatch.

Distribute where people pay attention, and don't overlook email

  1. Distribute where people pay attention, not where it's easy. Google confirmed under oath in the DOJ trial that user and usage data is a major ranking input. Rand expects AI to work the same way: the sources that matter will be the ones real people read. Listicles nobody clicks on a dead subreddit won't hold up.
  2. Don't forget email. Average email click-through rates have barely moved in 30 years. SparkToro now puts the full content inside its newsletter instead of chasing clicks, and subscriptions, opens and retention all went up.

Drop traffic as the KPI and measure real lift instead

  1. Stop using traffic as the main KPI. HubSpot lost a large share of its organic traffic last year and hit record stock prices anyway. Traffic down, revenue up.
  2. Measure with incrementality, not referrals. Rand points to Nabisco's 1955 Oreo test: a billboard in one city, none in a similar city, then compare sales. Run the same kind of test with your channels, track audience, reach, interest and sales together, and use an AI model to help interpret the patterns. If you only fund channels that get referral credit, he warns, Google will take credit for everything.

Links now act as citations that tell AI your brand is worth naming

Rand's talk doesn't make links less important. It changes what a good one is. A link is now as much a citation as a source of traffic: proof that a real publication, read by real people, thinks your brand is worth naming. That's exactly the signal AI tools draw on when they decide who to recommend.

How Page One Power builds the citations AI relies on

Here's how we're putting that into practice at Page One Power:

  • Placements on sites people actually read. We build links on real, relevant publications, not networks or pages nobody visits, because Rand is right that attention will decide which sources count.
  • Earned media that spreads your brand name. Digital PR and our Media Blitz campaigns put data-driven stories in front of hundreds of news and media outlets. Every pickup is a brand mention AI can learn from, linked or not.
  • Showing up in the communities AI cites. Our Reddit Visibility program places genuine, reviewed contributions in the threads that LLMs and Google surface most.
  • Content built to be the answer. Comparison, "versus" and roundup content, supported by links from relevant sites, gives AI something specific to quote.
  • Reporting on more than referrals. We track links, rankings, AI citations and brand search together, because traffic alone will undercount what's working.

Falling clicks aren't your fault, but getting named is now your job

If your clicks are falling while impressions climb, you're not doing anything wrong. The web changed. The job now is to make sure your brand is the one being named. If you'd like help figuring out where that should start for you, let's talk.